Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark Big Toe MaskTrick or Treat Studios and CBS are proud to present the Big Toe from the motion picture Scary Stories To Tell In The Dark. One of the famous stories from Alvin Schwartz's Scary Stories to Tell in the Darks is the Big Toe. In this story, a boy finds a severed toe in his garden, and the owner of that toe comes to reclaim it. The toe's owner happens to be long dead. This amazing mask is a beautiful replica of Big Toe. Every detail of the Big Toe is here